By Martin Smith -- 16 December 2022
Download the newsletter as a PDF (it has the photos and diagrams that are not on this page).
S&BCC News – Bumper Seasonal Issue! Club New Year Rapid – Anniversary Rapid – New venue x 2 – Library Group – Club AGM – POTYs results! – Tournaments – False moves – Barking – Game of the Century – Bonus!
Follow us on Twitter @Streathamchess – Website streathamchess.org. This issue of the Club magazine comes as one PDF, with links. We hope it works for you. If not please email the editor Martin Smith (contact details are in the PDF newsletter).
Lots to read in this Bumper issue – both here and via the links. Unattributed bits by Martin Smith; loads by other club members. Enjoy, and have a great seasonal break!
Welcome in the New Year at our club rapid. Six rounds over two evenings (7.30 kick off) – 25 minutes all moves. ECF rated. Entry will be free, but voluntary donations to cover venue costs will be much appreciated. Club Members and Library Group players all welcome. Email Richard Tillett to register (contact details are in the PDF newsletter).
Our 150th Anniversary celebrations came to a magnificent conclusion in a 40-strong Rapid on Saturday 17th September 2022 at the Mark Bennett Streatham Centre. It was played over six hard-fought rounds at 25 minutes plus 5 seconds per minute. There was a strong contingent of 16 from S&BCC, with another 16 or so other clubs represented. We were also delighted to welcome two juniors from Ukraine: Sasha Andronova, who has already been playing for us in the Croydon League, and Bohdan Terler of Maidenhead CC.
James Toon (far left), the editor (middle) and Richard Tillett (right)
S&BCC member James Toon (far left in pic) was Tournament Controller for the day. He was super-efficient in keeping things to a tight schedule (thanks, James!), aided and abetted by Richard Tillett (right) and Paul Ritchie from the club Management Team – with your editor (middle) trying to keep up.
We were delighted that Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP for Streatham was able to open the tournament. We presented her with a copy of Movers and Takers (our club history – if you’ve not yet got your copy we hope to put it online soon), and she reciprocated by generously sponsoring a prize. Thanks Bell!
Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP with Venkat
She kicked things off by playing the ceremonial first move (1. e4!). The pace in both sections was then set by the eventual winners: S&BCC’s Venkataramanan Tiruchirapalli (Major) – seen left with Bell – and Bohdan Terler (Minor). They both fought through without losing a game, each winning a £100 first prize. ‘Well done’ to them both. Runners-up were Richard Cannon (UNATS), and Gokhan Kizilay (Lewisham) in the Major and Minor respectively (£50 each). Grading prizes of £40 went to Zafar Iqbal (Kings Head/S&BCC), and Alex Spencer (S&BCC).
A word of thanks to all participants for making it such a memorable event to round off our 150th celebrations, to Vincia Bennett and her colleagues at Streatham Library for their helpful support, and to Harry Morgan and other club members for helping out with table shifting, etc.
Final tournament tables can be seen here:
And so, our year and a half of 150th Anniversary celebrations is over. Thanks to everyone who made it happen. Here’s to the next 150 years!
On November 8th our four-board Croydon League C team played our first match at our new venue: the Café at St.Thomas’ Church, Telford Avenue. Our opponents, Coulsdon C, had no trouble finding it and the venue worked brilliantly. On this occasion we used the regular café tables, though there are standard trestles available for larger matches.
We drew the match 2 v 2, with wins for new members Pierre McLean, board 4 and his mum Valerie McLean on board 3. Bad luck Matthew Evans-Young (another new member) on board 3, and club veteran and captain David Varley on 1, who both went down on this occasion.
Looking forward to seeing you all at St. Thomas’ for the club rapid 3 & 10 January and/or as the season progresses.
The new chess tables on Streatham Common (thanks to Angus for the photo)
Thanks to the Friends of Streatham Common (with a watching brief from S&BCC), our local green space is the capital’s newest open-air chess venue. These three super chess tables are up at the top of the common by the Rookery café.
But remember to bring your own pieces – and maybe a blanket or two (and a cushion?). We expect to see the new tables in use for combat at the Common Christmas Fair on Sunday 18th December. Chess is breaking out all over: it would be good if we local chessers could show them how it is done!
We endured a couple of chilly weeks in November when the Library’s central heating was broken (it’s been fixed now), but numbers have been good, with typically 20 or so chessers and their parents/carers at peak time (usually around 6.00-6.30).
There’s a regular core group and most weeks there’s a newcomer or two checking us out. In addition, there’s a much larger number of once-in-a-while folks who we don’t see so often. It’s always a pleasure to welcome back people who last came in those distant days before Covid landed.
Visitors to London stop by from time to time, and we even had a grandmaster from Spain join our sessions for a couple of weeks to play some blitz games with us. I don’t know if anyone took a game off him, but he certainly made short work of me.
We’ll be open as usual during the Christmas and New Year period except for Tuesday 27 December when the Library will be closed.
STOP PRESS! A journalist and a photographer from a local newspaper, the Brixton Blog & Bugle, visited us recently and saw for themselves ‘the joy of community chess’. Click here to see their feature.
This was our first AGM since OTB chess resumed and it was a relief to get back to something resembling business as usual. For the 2022/23 season we decided to increase our presence in the two central London leagues and the Croydon League, while trimming back our representation in the Surrey League because of difficulties getting players out for away matches.
Our finances are in good shape. We posted a small surplus for the 2021-22 season despite lower player turnout (due to the lingering impact of covid) and extra expenditure to support our 150th anniversary events. Our healthy financial performance was due largely to the fantastic support of our membership base who gave generous donations plus a number of players paying full subscriptions when they only played a handful of games.
The AGM decided to keep subscription rates at same level for 2022/23 as in the previous season: £45 for full membership; £22.50 for concessionary membership (including juniors), and a £4.50 game fee. We’ve been able to maintain subscription levels at the same level for five years and we remain one of the lowest cost clubs in London.
Chess clubs depend on members helping with the considerable volume of admin. More assistance would be greatly appreciated, particularly with keeping the club website up-to-date. If you think you might be able to help, please drop me an email or call me (contact details are in the PDF newsletter).
The annual Player Of The Year (POTY) award has been running since 2008/9. The POTY is a member who has done sterling service that season for the club: in the front line at the board (OTB and/or Online), and possibly also behind the scenes as a captain or organiser. The club management team consults team captains before making the award at the AGM.
John Hodgson (right) receives the Player of the Year trophy
Last season (2020-21) it was awarded to John Hodgson for his excellent results (8.5/14) in the OL4NCL (playing on boards 1 or 2 for the first team), stepping up also to take over the reins of our re-emerging team in the London League. John lives in Essex, and your Keeper of the Trophy had to wait until the Anniversary Rapid to grab a chance to make a formal presentation (see photo).
Belated congratulations to John!
James Toon with the trophy (selfie)
We were on schedule with the award this year (2021-22), presenting the trophy to James Toon (selfie) at the AGM. James solidly supported our London League OTB effort, and excelled in the organisation of our two highly successful club Online tournaments and the Anniversary Rapid – for which he was the Tournament Controller. He is now running our London League 1st and Eastman Cup teams. Oh, and by the way, James won both the club Online tournaments, each with a clean sheet. So, congratulations to James!
You don’t have to have the best score over the season to be the POTY. We have always tried to recognise enthusiasm and support for our teams – whatever your results – and willing contribution to the overall club effort. We have had POTYs from all playing strengths (as shown below): your name could be on the trophy next year. So, get stuck in, and start your POTY training now.
POTY Roll of Honour
It’s still early days in many of the Leagues, but here is the latest:
For various reasons our league campaign did not start until 1 December, two months into the league season. We went down 2.5 v 5.5 to a strong Hammersmith 1 team. Venkat and John C won on the top two boards, Robin secured his trademark peaceful draw lower down, but the rest of us were simply outgunned. It was a different story for our second match, where despite the rail strike we inflicted an 8–0 whitewash on Kings Head 1. Well done especially to Richard and Ruairi who beat higher-rated opposition on boards 7 and 8.
We are aiming to field teams led by any first team members still available on the top boards, followed by our 1900-1600 players (8-bds in all). We lost our first engagement 2.5 v 5.5 to strong Cavendish 2, drew 4 v 4 with Lewisham 1 in our second, then lost 3 v 5 to East Ham. Our sole winner in that match was Andrew Ponting who annotates his super win (with White, against D. Nikolaienko ECF 2125) in a gambit line against the French (by transposition). Andrew says: ‘I was pretty happy with my game, for my general positivity and crunching conclusion’. See it on Lichess here.
12 Nfxd5 - would you have played it?
1. d4 d5 2. Nc3 Nf6 3. Bg5 e6 4. e4 Be7 5. e5 Nfd7 6. h4 Bxg5 7. hxg Qxg5 8. Nh3 Qh4 9. g3 Qe7 10. Qd2 (I was seeing dangers in ….Qb4 that just aren’t there – I can always afford to give the b2 or d4 pawns given my lead in development. 10.Nf4 or 10. Qg4 were the moves.) 10…a6 11. Nf4 c5?? 12.dxc?? (I spent a long time looking at 12.Nfxd5, but couldn’t see some knockout blow. Stockfish is confident though that it was the best move, but as a positional sac rather than tactical. If I was a stronger player, I’d have realised that. Having bottled 12.Nfxd5 I felt I had to open lines, even if I lost a few pawns.) 12…Nxe5 13. 0-0-0 Qc5 (Feels greedy). 14. Ne4?! (Missing my chance. 13.Nh5 was the move, probably forcing 13….Rg8, given 13…0-0 14.Ng7) 14….Qe7 -/+ 15. Nh5 (hoping for 15…de 16Ng7 Kf8 17 Qh6 Kg8 18Nh5, but…) 15….f6 (15…f5 was even stronger, forcing me to retreat, and leaving Black an advantage.) 16. Nc3 Nbc6 17. f4 Ng4? (Stockfish suggests 17…d4 which hadn’t occurred to me) 18. Nxd5 (Belatedly) 18…Qf7 ?? (After which Black is immediately completely busted. 18..de 19.Re1 Nge5 would leave Black fine/slightly better.) 19. Nb6 Rb8 20. Bc4 g6 21. Nxc8 Rxc8 22. Bxe6 Qc7 23. Bxg4 (23. Bxc8 was probably cleaner) 23…f5 24. Nf6+ Kf7 25. Nxh7 fxg 26. Ng5+ Kf6 27. Qc3+ (27 Rh8 was mate in 8, but 27 Qc3 is also decisive) 27…Ne5 28. Qxc7 1-0 (If 28…Nd3+ 29 cxd, or cleaner still 29. Kb1).
We have played four matches, winning three and losing one. Currently we are 2nd in the table, behind West London. We seem to be the only two clubs taking this event seriously and should finish 1st and 2nd. The return match in February will be a six-pointer. With a squad of 12 competing for four places in the team, I am practising squad rotation, but will choose the strongest available team for that match.
We have restricted our SCCA participation to the Alex Cup. After a first-round bye we knocked out lower-graded Wallington 8.5 v 1.5, with Phil, Graham, Jagdip, Mark, James, Chris, Richard and Ruairi all victorious (Zafar drew; your editor lost). So, we are now in the semi’s and face mighty Kingston on January 17th in the new year. We are the home team, and a three-line whip is in force for our strongest players.
We’ve increased our participation in the Central London League (CLL), playing in Pimlico, by adding a 5 board 1st team in the 2nd Division to complement our existing team in the bottom tier. We had a tough start with our teams winning their opening matches then losing the next three – so now both are second from bottom in their divisions.
There’s still a lot to play for in the New Year, with three new players - Pierre McLean, Matt Hanney, and Ed Mospan – boosting our CLL 2nd team (which provides plenty of opportunities for newer and/or lower graded members to try our league chess). And for higher rated players, used to playing only in the Surrey or London leagues, the CLL 1st team offers the enticement of a different league and venue.
Our Croydon League D team has made a cracking start to the season with wins against West Wickham D and last year’s division winners, Lewisham D. Our C team drew against Coulsdon C, while our A and Rapid teams have yet to play their first matches. We have 23 matches in the Croydon League this season, of which we have played just three, so there will be lots of chess on offer in the coming months.
Angus French (White) against the Latvian Gambit: what is White’s killer idea on move 13?
Streatham entered two teams in the 4NCL Online competition, which started during Covid and is now in its sixth season. Interest has dropped off a bit as players return to OTB chess, but there were still 44 different clubs, and 102 teams playing across five divisions. Our A team, in the top division, was able to field a strong 2000+ effort on all boards, helped by the addition of some very strong Watford players joining us for this Online season. The B team, in the fourth division, fielded players from ECF 1300 up to 2100. Both teams performed well, but both unfortunately ended in 3rd position which meant neither qualified for the semi-finals. In Round 3 Angus French demonstrated how to refute Black’s notoriously dodgy Latvian Gambit.
See if you can spot White’s killer idea on move 13 (in the diagram) which Angus eventually played two moves later.
Full game score here: https://lichess.org/McBHCIqh#24
He’s in there somewhere
When I previously took part in the British Championships in Aberystwyth in 2014, I hadn’t played since qualifying the summer before. After a disappointing performance I concluded that if I ever made it again, at least one tough tournament beforehand was a necessity.
I did qualify again, at Paignton in the autumn of 2019…and then came Covid. By the time I got to Torquay in 2022, I had gone nearly three years without a proper game, and no tough warm-up. Consequently, I started with 0/3 and lost at least one further game I might have won. I don’t suppose I’ll ever get a third go, however the important thing is that I did qualify, did play, and that I met my minimum pre-tournament expectations by winning a game, this one.
I was glad, some way before the end of the Championship, to agree quick draws, which at least enabled me to get to a couple of football matches - as well as watch the fantastic deciding last-round game between Matthew Wadsworth and Harry Grieve. They are proper players though - the rest of us just try to do our best. And you can’t do your best without regular practice, no matter how many thousand blitz and rapid games you play online.
Mine was a lower-profile outing than Justin’s in the Championship. The event started unpromisingly as my train journey to Torquay took 8 hours on the Friday of the opening, and I was forced to take an emergency bye in round 1. Things improved after that with three wins and one loss, for a final score of 3.5/5 and a placing of 11th= out of 104.
At the beginning of November, I played in the well-established three-day Central London Congress at Imperial College. Generous move rate (90m + 30spm); comfortable playing conditions; ECF and FIDE-rated; over-18s only (due to licensing restrictions): what’s not to like? Last November, I came =2nd in the U2000 section with 4/5: could I do better?
Playing again in the U2000 section (where I was 5th seed on paper) I eventually prevailed in Round 1 after a long pawn endgame (last year I had lost in the opening round so already an improvement). In Round 2 my opponent fell into a well-known trap in the Scotch Gambit and had to give up a piece on move 8 to avoid mate. 2/2. On Saturday afternoon I played Latvian Aivar Jefremov (who has played a bit in the past for Streatham & Brixton).
In a line of the French Tarrasch I offered an early draw, but Aivar thought we had to play a minimum number of moves (30?). The arbiter said ‘no’ - and it was nice to have the evening off. In the penultimate round on Sunday morning, I won again and so went into the final round with top seed Colum Jezierski, also on 3½, just behind leader Oliver Finnegan on 4.0, who I was drawn to play. My destiny was in my own hands! I had the white pieces again – and won! – in a French Tarrasch again (see full score here). Colum also won, so we shared the £250 first prize. I also picked up 26 ECF rating points for my troubles.
White’s tactic on move 16 in Antony’s Round 5 game
As ever, you only win tournaments with a combination of lots of luck, stamina and the odd good move. Spot White’s tactic (in the diagram) on move 16 in my Round 5 game against the eventual runner-up. I won a pawn, and later the game.
The scandal of (alleged) cheating in GM OTB chess has made it to the national press. Whether the publicity is good or bad for the game, time will tell. Scandals in cricket (ball-tampering, body-line bowling), football (the hand of God, shirt-pulling), boxing (too numerous to list), etc, haven’t done any lasting damage: it’s gamesmanship. By contrast, drug-based performance enhancement in athletics is an existential threat akin to computer assistance in OTB chess. The latter is a necessarily modern phenomenon (quaintly, when Deep Blue beat Gazza in 1967 his allegation was that the computer had improper assistance from a human), and – for OTB anyway – antidotes will surely be found.
Leaving intentional cheating aside, look here at some examples of rule-breaking in serious chess, all be it accidental. The first one appeared in a local club game a few years back. It may be an example of something more common than we all realise: the illegal move double oversight. It was reported at the time on the club website here: https://streathamchess.org/2016/01/21/martin.html My opponent was the genial Nick Keene of Wimbledon CC who sadly died suddenly in June 2022.
For further examples of inadvertent illegalities go to this post (no longer online) in Rodney Barking’s blog (archived copy)
To satisfy our curiosity Mr Barking kindly provided the potted chess biography below. We asked him for a selfie, but he was too shy to oblige. Could this be him?
Rodney Dylan Dreadnought Randall Barking, aka Rodney Barking, discovered chess at the age of 10 when his grandfather gave him a chessboard and £1 to buy the pieces. He taught himself to play from ‘Chess for Children’ Raymond Bott and Stanley Morrison [both members of S&BCC in the 1960s – Ed]. At school in Leicestershire he was a big fish in a small chess pond, and he dreamed of becoming world champion [Didn’t we all – Ed]. Reality intervened at the county junior championships when he finished some way behind contemporaries Mark Hebden and Glenn Flear. Undaunted he took on his first captaincy at the age of 15 with the Loughborough 3rd team, and soon he was captain of an Oxford University team. On moving to London, he joined the nearest chess club: Streatham & Brixton [Aha! – Ed]
Rodney’s appetite for the game knew no bounds. When he joined the Civil Service, he revived the dormant Home Office Chess Club, playing in the Civil Service League and the London Commercial League. For the Civil Service Chess Association he volunteered for, and did, anything: from adjudicator (though later he disliked adjudication on principle) to General Secretary. Now believing that running everything was his duty and calling, he came to the attention of the medical profession. He was diagnosed with Eton Syndrome.
More recently, Rodney founded the Central London League, and the London Public Service League. [And is active again in S&BCC – Ed] His latest venture is online correspondence chess and this year he has started over 100 games. He was honoured to represent his country in international friendlies against Mexico and the Philippines. He is currently playing in the British Championships Candidates Tournament.
Thanks Rodney, we know you a bit better now; but please don’t overindulge again on Eton Mess.
Thanks to James Toon for this game.
Play through the moves here: https://lichess.org/study/zTGNuSvW
Commentary by James, fireworks from Robin.
Robin Haldane – James Toon, Civil Service League, 1996
C44: Scotch, Goering Gambit
Welcome to the 19th Century…
After 9….Ng4
1.e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6 3.d4 exd4 4.c3 dxc3 5.Bc4 cxb2 6.Bxb2 (The Danish Gambit. In true Haldane style, Robin sacrifices two pawns for a lead in development, open lines and an attack.) 6…d6 (6…Bb4+ 7.Nc3 Nf6 is a decent alternative. Black will castle, play …d6 and start defending.) 7. Qb3 Qd7 8.Bc3 Nh6 9.Na3 Ng4 (It’s all about e5. I was planning …f6 and …Nge5 to mount a barricade and stop White pushing the pawn.) 10.O-O-O? (What? This move offers the exchange and a pawn, just to remove one of Black’s defenders. Can it be sound? I couldn’t work it out at the board, so decided not to take on f2. However…) 10…f6 (Meant to prevent e5, but White plays it anyway. Instead 10…Nxf2 11.e5 Nxd1 12.Rxd1 d5 13.Bxd5 Bc5 and Black keeps the extra material and survives.)
11.e5 fxe5 12.Rhe1 Qe7 13.Rd5 g6? (There is no time for this. 13…Bd7 planning to castle long was the safer course here.) 14.h3 Bh6+ (I was planning to retreat but White keeps sacrificing material on e5 until eventually he wins my queen: 14…Nf6 15. Nxe5 dxe5 16.Rdxe5 Nxe5 17.Rxe5.) 15.Kb2 Be6? (I can’t remember why I played this. White gets two pieces for a rook and the attack continues.) 16.hxg4 Bxd5 17.Bxd5 Bg7 (Black is one move away from consolidating. Unfortunately that’s one move too far… ) 18.Qxb7
After 18 Qxb7
18…Rb8 (White’s queen is pinned – but at what cost?) 19.Bxc6+ Kf7 20. Bd5+ Kf6 (Retreating to the back rank breaks the connection between the rooks and allows Qxb8+.) 21.g5+ Kf5 22.g4+ Kxg4 (Robin sensed (correctly) that checkmate was now on and spent most of his remaining time looking for the killer blow.)
Looking for the killer blow
23.Re4+? (This wasn’t it. Instead the game should finish 23.Rg1+ Kh5 24.Be4 Rxb7+ 25.Ka1 I have a material advantage of queen, rook and three pawns for three minor pieces, but it’s not enough. 25…Qxg5 26.Rxg5+ Kh6 27.Bd2 Bf8 28.Rxg6+ Kh5 29.Rg5+ Kh6 30.Rg4+ Kh5 31.Rh4#) 23…Kf5 24.Bd2 Rxb7+ 25.Kc2 (Quite rightly not capturing on b7. The bishop is needed on d5 where it stops the black king escaping via e6.) 25…Qxg5 (Giving up my queen is the only way to avoid mate.) 26. Bxg5? (As soon becomes apparent, Robin should have captured on g5 with the knight rather than the bishop.) 26…c6 27. Bxc6 Rc7 28.Rc4 Rhc8 29.Bd7+ Rxd7 30.Rxc8 (All this was forced. Now Black gets a piece back. This wouldn’t work with the knight rather than the bishop on g5.) 30…e4 31. Nd2 Kxg5 32.Nxe4+ Kf4 33.Nd2 d5 34.Kd3 h5 (I decided my best plan was to push the h-pawn and try to tie down some of White’s pieces.)
35.Ke2 h4 36.Kf1 h3 37.Kg1 g5 38.Nc2 g4 39.Ne1 Kf5 40.Nd3 Bh6 (Here, stronger would have been 40…Rb7 41.Nf1 Rb1 42.Rc1 Rxc1 43.Nxc1 d4 when a draw is the most likely outcome.) 41.Nf1 Bg7 42.Ng3+ Kg5 43.Rc6 Rb7 (Now White should maintain the pressure with Rc5 and win eventually. But both players were very short of time.) 44.Nc5 Rb1+ 45.Kh2 Bf6? (Here I should have played 45…Be5 46.Ne6+ Kh4 47.Nf8 Bxg3+ 48.fxg3+ Kh5 with a drawn position. Now 46.Rd6 and White is winning again.) 46.Ne6+ Kg6 (Avoiding 46…Kh4 47.Rc7 and Black is caught in a mating net.) 47.Nf4+ Kf7? (Another blunder. 47…Kg5 holds the draw.) 48.Rc7+ Ke8 49.Rxa7? (Bringing up the cavalry with Nxd5 or Nf5 would win for White.) 49…Rb2 50.Nxd5 Rxf2+ 51.Kh1
(The players did not record any more moves because we were both too short of time. Despite the unusual material position, the game is now drawn. As I recall we played on for a further 20 moves before shaking hands. 0.5 – 0.5)
For a bonus treat, please see Alex Spencer’s brilliant Three Act Play: ‘The Queen of Southfields’ – describing, in vivid detail, his school chess club’s recent campaign in the National Schools Chess Championship. Click here for the full script.